‹ Back

New Divorce Laws Coming to South Africa: Safeguarding the Welfare of Children in Muslim Marriages

Introduction

In a significant development, the South African Cabinet has given its approval for the submission of the draft Divorce Amendment Bill of 2023 to Parliament. This bill seeks to introduce crucial changes to the existing Divorce Act 1997, with a specific focus on safeguarding the welfare of minor or dependent children born of Muslim marriages. Furthermore, it aims to address the issue of patrimonial benefits and their redistribution upon the dissolution of a Muslim marriage. These proposed amendments are a response to the Constitutional Court's ruling in June 2022, which found the original Divorce Act to be inconsistent with the Constitution as it excluded Muslim marriages. Moreover, the 1979 Act unfairly discriminated against children of both married and unmarried parents.

Proposed Amendments to the Divorce Act

The draft Divorce Amendment Bill of 2023 consists of five key clauses that aim to rectify the unconstitutional aspects of the existing Divorce Act. These clauses include:

Clause 1: Recognition of Muslim Marriages

This clause introduces a new definition of Muslim marriage, which aligns with the Constitutional Court's judgment and acknowledges it as part of South Africa's common law.

Clause 2: Safeguarding Mechanisms for Minors and Dependants

Under this clause, section 6 of the Divorce Act will be amended to provide specific mechanisms for protecting the welfare of minors or dependants in Muslim marriages.

Clause 3: Redistribution of Assets

Section 7 of the Divorce Act will be amended to empower the court to make orders regarding the redistribution of assets upon the dissolution of a Muslim marriage.

Clause 4: Forfeiture of Patrimonial Benefits

This clause proposes amending section 9 of the Divorce Act to enable the court to order the forfeiture of patrimonial benefits in Muslim marriages under specified terms and conditions.

Clause 5: Short Title and Commencement

Clause 5 deals with the short title and commencement of the Act, ensuring its proper implementation.

The Definition of Muslim Marriage

According to section 1 of the Divorce Amendment bill, the proposed definition of Muslim marriage encompasses marriages conducted in accordance with Islamic Law, also known as Shariah. This definition includes the regulation of public and private behavior based on traditional customs (Al-Urf) derived from primary sources such as the Quran and Sunnah (Prophetic model). Additionally, it incorporates juristic tools like ijma (the consensus) of Muslim Jurists and the individual jurist's qiyas (analogical deductions) to issue legal edicts.

The Quest for Inclusive Legislation

The Al Jama-Ah political party made significant strides towards inclusivity by introducing two private member bills to Parliament in late 2022. These bills proposed changes to divorce and marriage laws, advocating for the inclusion of Muslim marriages. The leader of the party, Mogamad Ganief Hendricks, emphasized the dire consequences faced by Muslim marriages and households due to the absence of adequate legal remedies provided by the Divorce Act.

Addressing the Diverse Population of South Africa

South Africa's rich diversity necessitates regulators and legislation to continually adapt to the evolving societal landscape. Presently, family law regulations do not encompass certain religious marriages, such as those conducted under Muslim, Hindu, and other customary practices observed within African families. As a result, the proposed amendments to the Divorce Act and the introduction of the Draft Marriages Bill aim to bridge this gap and establish a comprehensive marriage policy that applies universally to all citizens.

FAQs (Frequently Asked Questions)

Q: Why were Muslim marriages excluded from the original Divorce Act?

A: The Constitutional Court deemed the exclusion of Muslim marriages from the original Divorce Act unconstitutional, as it violated the principles of equality and non-discrimination.

Q: How will the proposed amendments safeguard the welfare of children in Muslim marriages?

A: The amendments will introduce specific mechanisms within the Divorce Act to ensure the welfare of minor or dependent children in Muslim marriages, providing them with necessary legal protections.

Q: What is the significance of redistributing assets in the dissolution of a Muslim marriage?

A: Asset redistribution aims to address equitable distribution and fairness in the dissolution of a Muslim marriage, ensuring that both parties are treated justly.

Q: How will the proposed amendments address the issue of patrimonial benefits in Muslim marriages?

A: The amendments empower the court to order the forfeiture of patrimonial benefits in Muslim marriages under stipulated terms and conditions, promoting fairness and addressing any imbalances.

Q: What is the purpose of the Draft Marriages Bill?

A: The Draft Marriages Bill aims to establish a universal marriage policy applicable to people of all backgrounds, ensuring inclusivity and equal treatment.

Q: Will the proposed amendments affect marriages of other religions or customs?

A: While the focus of the amendments is on Muslim marriages, the broader objective is to create legislation that accommodates various religious and customary practices, promoting fairness and equality.

Conclusion

The proposed amendments to the Divorce Act in South Africa mark a significant step towards rectifying the historical exclusion of Muslim marriages from legal protections. These amendments not only address the welfare of minor or dependent children but also ensure the equitable distribution of assets and the forfeiture of patrimonial benefits. By embracing inclusivity and accommodating the diverse population, South Africa aims to establish comprehensive marriage policies that uphold the principles of fairness and justice for all its citizens.